What is the Difference between Income Protection and Serious Illness Cover in Ireland?

 

Choosing between Income Protection Insurance and Serious Illness Cover in Ireland involves understanding their differences, benefits, and drawbacks. We will compare the types of coverage, features and provide insights into which might offer more value to an individual based on one’s specific needs and scenarios.

 

Serious Illness Cover: Serious illness cover, also known as critical illness insurance, provides a lump sum payment if you are diagnosed with one of the specified illnesses listed in the policy. These typically include life-threatening conditions such as cancer, heart attack, stroke, and other major health issues. 

 

Income Protection Insurance: Income protection insurance offers a regular income if you are unable to work due to illness or injury. This payment typically covers a percentage of your usual income and continues until you can return to work, retire, or the policy term ends.

 

 

 

Advantages of Income Protection

 

• 1. Regular Income: Provides continuous financial support, ensuring monthly expenses and lifestyle can be maintained during the period of illness or injury.
  2. Comprehensive Coverage: Generally covers a broader range of conditions, including mental health issues and musculoskeletal problems like back, hip, and knee issues.
  3. Flexibility: Payments continue until you can return to work or reach retirement age, offering long-term security.
  4. Tax-deductible Premiums: Premiums are tax-deductible, which means you can get tax relief at your marginal rate on the premiums you pay, thereby reducing the overall cost of the policy.

 

 

Disadvantages of Income Protection

 

• 1. Waiting Period: There is usually a waiting period (deferred period) before payments commence, ranging from a few weeks to several months.
  2. Percentage of Income: This typically covers only a portion of your income (usually up to 75%), which might not fully replace your salary.
  3. Cost: It can be more expensive than serious illness cover due to its comprehensive nature.

 

 

 

 

Advantages of Serious Illness Cover

 

• 1. Lump sum payment: Provides a significant one-time payment and an immediate financial relief that can be used at the policyholder’s discretion, such as paying off a mortgage, medical bills, or other expenses.
  2. Financial Security: Offers financial relief at a critical time, especially if the illness requires extensive treatment and recovery.
  3. Simplicity: Once the claim is approved and paid, there are no further interactions with the insurer regarding the same illness.
  4. Tax-free: Payouts are typically tax-free.

 

Disadvantages of Serious Illness Cover

 

• 1. Specific Illnesses Only: Coverage is limited to illnesses listed in the policy, which may not cover all possible health issues.
  2. Claim Conditions: Strict conditions and definitions must be met to qualify for a payout.
  3. Ongoing Support: After the lump sum payment, no further financial support is provided, regardless of the duration of the illness.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Income Protection Case Study: Choosing the Right Insurance

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Scenario Analysis

 

Scenario 1: Chronic Back Pain

• Income Support: David develops chronic back pain that prevents him from working. After the 13-week deferred period, his income protection policy pays €4,375 monthly. This allows him to cover his rent, loan payments, and other expenses without financial strain.
• Rehabilitation: The policy may also provide support for physiotherapy, aiding his recovery and potential return to work.

 

Scenario 2: Mental Health Issues

• Continuous Coverage: David experiences severe stress and anxiety, impacting his ability to work. The income protection policy covers mental health conditions, ensuring he receives financial support during treatment and recovery.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Serious Illness Case Study: Choosing the Right Insurance

 

 

 

Client Profile:

• Name: Mary O’Sullivan
• Age: 45
• Occupation: High School Teacher
• Annual Salary: €50,000
• Family: Married with two children (ages 10 and 14)
• Financial Obligations: Mortgage (€200,000 outstanding), education savings for children

 

 

Health and Financial Needs: Mary is in good health but has a family history of serious illnesses such as cancer and heart disease. She is concerned about the financial impact on her family if she were to be diagnosed with a serious illness. Mary wants to ensure that her family is protected financially in the event of a significant health issue.

 

 

Decision Factors

 

1. Immediate Financial Needs:
   • Mortgage and Debts: Mary’s primary concern is being able to pay off her mortgage and debts if she falls seriously ill.
   • Education Savings: She also wants to ensure there are sufficient funds for her children’s education.
2. Lump Sum Requirement:
   • One-Time Expenses: Mary anticipates that a lump sum payment would be more beneficial to cover immediate, large expenses such as mortgage repayment, home modifications if needed, and any advanced medical treatments not covered by public health services.
3. Coverage for Specific Illnesses:
   • Family History: Given her family history, Mary is particularly interested in coverage for cancer and heart disease, which are typically covered under serious illness policies.
4. Long-Term Financial Stability:
   • Spousal Support: Mary’s husband also works and can provide ongoing income support, reducing the necessity for a continuous income replacement provided by an income protection policy.

 

Choosing the Serious Illness Policy

Policy Selection: Mary decides to opt for a serious illness policy that offers a lump sum payment of €150,000 upon diagnosis of a covered condition. This policy is comprehensive, covering major illnesses such as cancer, heart attack, stroke, and others.

 

 

Scenario Analysis

 

Scenario 1: Diagnosis of Cancer

• Lump Sum Utilization: Upon being diagnosed with cancer, Mary receives the €150,000 payout. She uses €100,000 to pay down her mortgage and the remaining €50,000 for medical expenses and family support.

 

Scenario 2: Heart Attack

• Financial Management: If Mary suffers a heart attack, the lump sum allows her to focus on recovery without worrying about immediate financial pressures. The payout can cover treatment costs and help in making necessary lifestyle adjustments.

 

 

How does a Serious Illness Policy Benefit Mary?

 

1. Lump Sum Payment:
   • Immediate Debt Clearance: The €150,000 lump sum can be used to pay off a significant portion of the mortgage, reducing financial stress on her family.
   • Flexibility: The lump sum provides flexibility to manage other significant expenses, including medical bills and children’s education costs.
2. Focused Coverage:
   • Targeted Illnesses: The policy covers the specific serious illnesses that Mary is most concerned about due to her family history, ensuring targeted financial protection.
3. Cost-Effective:
   • Premium Affordability: Serious illness policies can be more affordable than income protection policies, making it easier for Mary to manage within her budget.
4. Simplicity:
   • Ease of Claim: The process of claiming a lump sum is straightforward once a diagnosis is confirmed, providing quick financial relief without the need for ongoing claim submissions.

 

Conclusion

For Mary, a serious illness policy offers a more suitable financial safety net compared to an income protection policy. The lump sum payment provides immediate and flexible financial relief, addressing her primary concerns about mortgage payments, education savings, and medical expenses. Given her family history and financial priorities, the serious illness policy ensures that she and her family are protected against the financial impact of major health issues.

 

 

 

Is Income Protection tax deductible in Ireland?

 

Premiums are tax-deductible in Ireland, which means you can get tax relief at your marginal rate on the premiums you pay, thereby reducing the overall cost of the policy. Benefits received, in this case, are generally considered taxable income.

 

 

Can I claim tax relief on Critical Illness Insurance?

 

Premiums are not tax-deductible, but the lump sum payout is usually tax-free.

 

 

How quickly can you claim Income Protection?

 

An Income Protection policy typically has a deferred period of 4 to 26 weeks before payments start. The deferred period on an income protection policy refers to the length of time you must be unable to work before you can make a claim.

 

You can select a deferred period of 4, 8, 13, 26, or 52 weeks. If you opt for a 4-week deferred period, you can file a claim on your income protection after being unable to work for 4 weeks. As a policyholder, you can make multiple claims if you suffer from different illnesses or the same illness re-occurs, provided you are still within the policy term.

 

 

In Ireland, the waiting period to claim serious illness cover usually involves a survival period after the diagnosis of a covered illness. This survival period typically ranges from 14 – 30 days, depending on the specific policy and insurer. This means that once diagnosed with a critical illness, you must survive for the duration of this specified period to be eligible for the claim payout.

 

Can I make multiple claims on a Serious Illness policy?

 

Yes, in Ireland, you can make multiple claims on a serious illness policy, but this depends on the terms and conditions of your specific policy.

 

Generally, you can claim for different illnesses as long as each illness is covered by the policy and you meet the policy criteria for each condition. Some policies may also allow multiple claims for different conditions under certain circumstances, while others may have limitations on the number of claims or the total amount that can be claimed. It is essential to review your policy details to understand the exact provisions and limitations regarding multiple claims.

 

 

Where to from here:

 

Deciding between income protection insurance and serious illness cover depends on your individual needs and financial circumstances. For those seeking comprehensive, long-term financial support in case of any illness or injury, income protection insurance might be a better option.

 

Conversely, if the priority is immediate financial relief upon diagnosis of a major illness, serious illness cover could be more suitable. Understanding the specific benefits, limitations, and costs of each type of insurance is crucial for making an informed decision. Be sure to contact our financial advisors to determine which plan is suitable for you.

E.&O.E.

 

Need to speak with a Financial Advisor?

Fill out your details and enquiry below, and one of our Qualified Financial Advisors will get back to you shortly.