Purchasing Property via Pension or Investing in High-Yield Equities

Purchasing Property via Pension or Investing in High-Yield Equities


Investing in property or high-yield equities are two common strategies for individuals seeking to maximize their retirement savings. Each option comes with its own set of advantages, risks, and tax implications. In Ireland, the choice between using pension funds to purchase property versus investing directly in high-yield equities can significantly impact one’s financial future. We will explore the advantages of both strategies, provide a comparative analysis, and offer an example illustrating the potential returns over a 20-year period.



Advantages of Purchasing Property via Pension


  1. Stable Income Stream: Property investments can provide a consistent rental income, which can be particularly attractive for retirees seeking a reliable income stream.
  2. Capital Appreciation: Over the long term, properties tend to appreciate in value, potentially offering significant capital gains.
  3. Tax Benefits: Using a self-administered pension fund to purchase property can offer substantial tax advantages. Rental income generated by the property within the pension is typically tax-free, and capital gains tax (CGT) on property sales within the pension is also avoided.
  4. Control over Investment: Direct property investment allows for greater control over the asset, including decisions related to maintenance, leasing, and eventual sale.


Advantages of Investing in High-Yield Equities


  1. Higher Potential Returns: Historically, equities have offered higher returns compared to most other asset classes. High-yield equities, in particular, can provide substantial dividend income and capital growth.
  2. Liquidity: Equities are generally more liquid than property investments, allowing investors to buy and sell shares with relative ease.
  3. Diversification: Investing in a range of high-yield equities can diversify risk across different sectors and geographic regions.
  4. Tax Efficiency: Dividends from equities can benefit from lower tax rates, and investing through pension schemes can defer taxes on dividends and capital gains until withdrawal.



Complete the form below to book a consultation - Purchasing Property via Pension or Investing in High-Yield Equities



Comparative Analysis Over 20 Years


To compare these two investment strategies, let’s consider the expected returns and tax implications of each over a 20-year period, using Irish tax rules.


Example Assumptions


Initial Investment: €200,000

Annual Rental Yield (Property): 5%

Annual Property Appreciation: 3%

Annual Dividend Yield (Equities): 4%

Annual Capital Growth (Equities): 6%

Irish Tax Rates: Standard income tax rate of 20%, higher rate of 40%, and a capital gains tax rate of 33%. Pension income withdrawals are taxed at the individual’s marginal rate.



Property Investment via Pension


  1. Annual Rental Income: €200,000 x 5% = €10,000 (tax-free within the pension)
  2. Property Value After 20 Years: Future Value = €200,000 x (1 + 0.03)^20 = €361,222
  3. Total Rental Income Over 20 Years: €10,000 x 20 = €200,000. Assuming the rental income is reinvested within the pension: Future Value of Rental Income = €10,000 x [(1 + 0.03)^20 – 1] / 0.03 = €268,506.
  4. Total Value After 20 Years: €361,222 (property) + €268,506 (reinvested rental income) = €629,728.


High-Yield Equities Investment


  1. Annual Dividend Income: €200,000 x 4% = €8,000.
  2. Future Value of Dividends: Assuming dividends are reinvested: €8,000 x [(1 + 0.10)^20 – 1] / 0.10 = €504,289.
  3. Equity Value After 20 Years: Future Value = €200,000 x (1 + 0.06)^20 = €641,427.
  4. Total Value After 20 Years: €641,427 + €504,289 = €1,145,716.



Tax Implications on Withdrawal


Property via Pension: Upon withdrawal, the total amount (€629,728) will be taxed at the individual’s marginal rate.

Equities via Pension: Similarly, the total amount (€1,145,716) will be taxed at the individual’s marginal rate.


Assuming a marginal tax rate of 40%:

Net Value (Property): €629,728 x (1 – 0.40) = €377,837.

Net Value (Equities): €1,145,716 x (1 – 0.40) = €687,430.




While both investment strategies offer significant benefits, the example shows that investing directly in high-yield equities has the potential to yield a higher net return after 20 years, even after accounting for taxes. Equities provide higher potential returns through capital growth and dividend reinvestment, along with greater liquidity and diversification. However, purchasing property via a pension can offer stable income and capital appreciation with attractive tax benefits, particularly for those seeking a more tangible asset. Ultimately, the choice depends on your risk tolerance, investment goals, and preference for control over the asset.


Need to speak with a Financial Advisor?

Fill out your details and inquiry below, and one of our Qualified Financial Advisors will get back to you shortly.

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.
I need help with: